And its another John Wayne special
rolls off the shelf. He is certainly a legend but really does lack something in the acting
department. Sorry to any John Wayne fans but this is reserved for mother viewing, and I
found it a bit a snoozer. Uncle Ethan (John Wayne) returns home to his brothers
house after the Civil War to find his nieces and nephews all grown up.
However the happy Texan outback is about to become a little unstable as a group of
rebel Comanche tear through the district. They begin by stealing and killing a neighbours
heard of cattle. Ethan heads out with the Texas rangers to find the Indians, instead they
find a dead heard of cattle. They immediately head home in fear of what is happening while
they are away. Sure enough the Indians have been through Ethans brothers house set it in
fire, killed his brother and wife and taken his 2 nieces.
The Texas rangers with Ethan at their side head off to find the two girls. Soon enough
there are differences and Ethan ends up splitting from the group with his nephew Martin
Pawley (Jeffery Hunter) and another man to find the girls. Lucy is found dead shortly
after but Debbie the eldest girl is still missing. They spend 5 years searching for them
finding Debbie eventually.
While all of this is going on Laurie (Vera Miles) is waiting at home for Martin to
return to marry her. She decides after 5 years and only one letter that he isnt
coming back to her so she decides to marry another. Martin does return just in time
though.
This is really a glorified Cowboy and Indians story that dragged on a little too long
and had so many cliches it became monotonous.
So How Does This Transfer Hold Up?
VIDEO
While this is far superior to Cowboys there is still some room for improvement. I
wont be too critical though considering the film is 45 years old. The disc is dual
sided with a full frame version on one side and a 1.75:1
Anamorphic widescreen transfer on the other. I admit I only watched parts of the
full frame version but watched the widescreen transfer entirely.
The main fault with the transfer was a prevalence of film artefacts, which really
became annoying after a while. There were no MPEG artefacts
Shadow detail was average and many of the darker scenes lacked a lot of detail.
Generally the image was quite sharp; given its age I was expecting it to be a lot
worse. There were some minor instances of grain but nothing too bad.
The colour palette was characteristic of most technicolour films in that it was washed
out and very dull. I wouldnt expect too much more though once again taking the age
of the film into consideration the technicolour images arent too bad.
There are some very minor instances of shimmering.
As a 45-year-old film I cant really place too much criticism on the transfer
quality.
AUDIO
Ok as a Dolby Digital Mono soundtrack this was certainly less than
spectacular. The centre channel took the entire load as far as speaker coverage
(surprise!). Dialogue was generally clear but sometimes got a little mumbly and needed a
volume boost.
As a mono soundtrack you cant really pick too much here, as there isnt much
to expect.
The best way to describe the musical score from max Steiner is "Typically
Western". Lots of dramatic strings and cowboys songs are the basis for the
soundtrack.
EXTRAS
Theatrical Trailer
Featurette: WB Presents:
A very nice and informative making of featurette which is well worth a look. Director John
Ford takes us behind the scenes and reveals some film making secrets that would have been
quite original in its time. The transfer quality here is plagued with film artefacts, and
doesnt seem to have had anywhere near as much attention as the film.
OVERALL
I can say that yes this is quite a good transfer but not my cup of tea. It certainly is
much better quality than the Cowboys. If you are a Western Movie fan than this would rate
as a classic so you should definitely see it.