Back to the MAIN PAGE

whitedot.gif (34 bytes)
News On-line Store Reviews
Release Info DVD Slicks Site Info
Visit DVD Station - OUR On-Line store

.

DVD Review 

.

blue_dot.jpg (285 bytes)
blue_dot.jpg (285 bytes)
blue_dot.jpg (285 bytes)blue_dot.jpg (285 bytes)
blue_lt_dot.jpg (646 bytes)

Cider House Rules
Reviewed by Matt Goldsmith

blue_lt_dot.jpg (646 bytes)
arc_ld.jpg (370 bytes) blue_lt_dot.jpg (646 bytes) arc_ld.jpg (370 bytes)

 

Online DVD Sales

Visit The Video Shift for Region 4 DVD

 

arc_lu.jpg (338 bytes) blue_dot.jpg (288 bytes) blue_dot.jpg (288 bytes) arc_ru.jpg (369 bytes)
blackbit.jpg (285 bytes)blue_dot.jpg (288 bytes)

cider.jpg (9185 bytes)
Director

Lasse Hallstrom

Cast
Tobey Maguire,
Charlize Theron,
Delroy Lindo,
Paul Rudd,
Jane Alexander,
Kathy Baker,
Kieren Culkin,
& Michael Caine

Music
Rachel Portman

blue_lt_dot.jpg (646 bytes)
Screen Format 2.35:1 (Anamorphic Widescreen)
Audio Tracks DD5.1 English
DD2.0 English
DD2.0 Commentary Track
Subtitles English
Region Code 4
Chapters 25
Disc Format RSDL (Layer Change on 78:18)
Running Time 120 minutes
Features - Original Theatrical Trailer
- Cast and Crew Bios
- Dolby Digital Aurora Trailer
- Featurette (Making of an American Classic)
- 5 Deleted Scenes
- Running Commentary
Classification M15+   (Low Level Violence, Medium Level Sex Scene, Adult themes)
Distributor Roadshow
Release date 22nd August 2000

THIS DVD is 16:9 Enhanced

blackbit.jpg (285 bytes)blue_dot.jpg (288 bytes)
arc_ld.jpg (370 bytes) blue_dot.jpg (288 bytes) blue_dot.jpg (288 bytes) arc_rd.jpg (381 bytes)

 

As many adapted screenplays are butchered from their source material it’s great to see an author tackle their own adaption for the big screen and not having it still reading like a book or stage play. John Irving scripted from his own novel of CIDER HOUISE RULES, and he must have done it right for he was honoured with an Academy Award for his Screenplay.

Touching on the very controversial subjuect of abortion, Cider does anything but dwell on this aspect. Rather, the theme of abortion is very much secondary to the story.

Cider establishes itself in a 1940’s Orphanage and follows the life of Homer Wells (Tobey Macguire) who has lived there all his life under the guidence of Dr Wilbur Larch (Michael Caine garnering the films 2nd academy award). Along the way, Dr Larch has been teaching him to be a sergeon with the intent of Homer one day replacing him.

Helping out Dr Larch, and for many years past, are Nurses Angela (Kathy Bates), and Edna (Jane Alexander). Together, these three form the parental units of St. Cloud’s Orphanage.

As often as the orphanage takes in unwanted babies, they also do their fair share of getting rid of unwanted babies by performing illegal abortions, for Dr Larch feels that it is a necessary procedure for him to perform due to the many dangerous backyard abortions occurring.

One such couple come to St Clouds to have an abortion Candy (Charlize Theoron) and Wally (Paul Rudd), and end up taking Homer with them back to their home town! Homer becomes an Apple picker for Wally’s mother, Olive (Kate Nelligan) , and also watches over Candy while he’s fighting in the war.

Pretty soon Homer and Candy are caught up in a passionate affair. Not only that, but the Cider House is involved in another shocking event involving the crew working the apple orchard.

So How Does This Transfer Hold Up?

VIDEO
Originating once again from the Miramax clan (like Halloween : H20 and Life is Beautiful), and distributed in OZ by Roadshow, Cider is presented in it’s original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.35:1 and is Anamorphic Widescreen to boot!

If there is ever a case that Digital Noise Reduction should be BANNED as an option of DVD players THIS film is the reason! After getting my player upgraded with the latest firmware to fix audio sync, it came back with the D.N.R feature Turned ON. Not realising this was so I Went ahead and reviewed Cider, and well let’s just say it was not in its favour. Thank God I popped on Shawshank Redemption and Noticed the same sort of problems and then Instantly realised what was up, as Shank’s is a superb transfer!!!! Sooo..here’s my second attempt at reviewing the VIDEO TRANSFER of Cider.

This Anamorphic Widescreen DVD is a joy to look at. Beautifully sharpened with a light use of diffusion, it’s just one striking scene after another! Once Homer hits the Road, the deliberately bleak look of the orphanage is no more, as colour saturation increases and black level drops a little, brightening things up very nicely indeed. With only a few moments of slight aliasing (car outlines and mainly the crane shot over the Orphanage toward the end of the film), and the odd bit of what appears to be Artifacting (the blue light background during Homers trip with Wally and Candy shifts every so slightly), it’s a transfer that is still well above average!!!
Cider is spread over 2 layers of an RSDL DVD with the layer change occurring within chapter 16 at the 78:18 minute mark.

AUDIO
Cider has been blessed with an absolutely beautiful music score by Rachel Portman (unfortunately denied a 3rd Oscar for Cider :). You can listen to the incredibly moving music on either the Dolby Digital 5.1 or Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround English tracks (the third track is the commentary). Whenever the music score kicks in, it simply fills the room  (and you will want to crank that volume up even higher to have this music envelope you even more!!!!).

Music aside, this is a dialogue driven film and is always clear and intelligible. However, it does waver ever so slightly out of sync from time to time (the effects of sloppy dialogue looping), and there are also a few light audio ‘pops’ in the mix. [I am told these audible pops originated from the master audio mix so nothing could be done for any release of this film] Curse these studios for using cheap dubbing houses to mix their films! (Miramax and New Line seem to be infamous for doing this with their films and it’s a pity that often the distributors like Roadshow are the one’s who cop all the flack! Wouldn’t it be wonderful if you really could make a silk purse out of a sows ear! :)

EXTRAS
In recent times, Miramax has gotten behind the 8 balls and started adding a few extras to their DVDs, and so Roadshow were able to secure the rights to a few goodies for this DVD release also! (if only Miramax did this much for their other oscar winning film, Life if Beautiful)

The static menus have the pleasure of a 5.1 audio mix (something I love to hear on DVDs menus!) and are nicely designed with easy navigation (which is even more important than 5.1 audio on menus :)

As is usual fair for Roadshow, all the extras are Anamorphic Widescreen (something I wish MORE distributors would start doing) and not only include English Subtitles for the Hearing Impaired(on the movie only), but also :-

5 deleted scenes totalling a good 8 minutes, all deleted scenes have their own chapter (Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround audio) and are of a decent qua

Theatrical Trailer – (1.78 aspect ratio, 2.0 surround sound encoded)

Cast and Crew Bios – Easy to read with plenty of trivia

Dolby Digital Aurora Trailer - always a most welcome extra

The Making of an American Classic – informative 22 minute making of featurette

Commentary Track – a very good commentary recorded the day after the Oscars! from Lasse Hallstrom(director), John Irving(writer/author), and Richard Gladstein(Producer).  With these boys obviously on cloud nine after their big win, it’s a treat to listen to.
(You may find Lasse a tad hard to understand at first, but for some reason he then suddenly becomes easier to understand….go figure! :)


Cider House Rules is a wonderfully uplifting film, despite it’s occasional subject matter and makes for a very nice DVD. (Good to see Gwenyth couldn’t intercept one of these Oscars! :)

PICTURE QUALITY   9/10 A very lush looking piccy
SOUND
- Quality
- 5.1 WOW Factor

  8/10 (great use of panning sound)
  8/10 (a totally enveloping music score)
FEATURES   9/10 some terrific extras


Review Equipment
TV: Pioneer SD-T50W1 (16:9 RPTV)
DVD: Pioneer DV717  (using RGB outputs)
Receiver/Decoder: Marantz SR870 & Sony SDP-EP9ES
Speakers:-
     Fronts: Quadral Phonolgue Gold Amun
     Centre: B&W CDMC-SE
     Rears: B&W 602
     Subby: M&K V125 

- Reviewed 24th August 2000

blackbit.jpg (285 bytes)

 
      Copyright 2000 by DVDown Under......this site looks best at 1024x768, but will get by at 800x600
      We FORBID you from  using 640x480 - go buy yourself a new 17" monitor right now!!!
      Found a Problem on this site or are just plain lonely, then please email us, email us now downunder@dvd.wow.aust.com