| Based on the novel by Oliver Sacks this is
one of the most moving films Ive ever had to review. Took me a while to dry the
tears by the end. Robin Williams and Robert De Niro play exceptional characters. Robin
Williams plays a constantly serious role in this film, which is executed with vigour and
brilliance. Doctor Sayer (Robin Williams) is a
research specialist who has only ever worked with plants and animals. In 1969 he is given
a neurologists position in a chronic hospital. Here he discovers a group of patients who
have been infected with encephalitis lethargica. These patients suffer from a
condition in which they appear to be awake but have al the symptoms of being asleep. They
dont speak or doing anything voluntarily.
Doctor Sayer discovers however that they have exceptional
reflex actions. He researches a drug L-DOPA that is generally used for the treatment of
patients with Parkinsons disease. His guinea pig patient (so to speak) is Leonard
(Robert de Niro). He treats Leonard with this new drug and slowly increases his dosage
until he is giving huge doses. Leonard then wakes in the middle of the night and almost
transforms into a normal human being. Dr. Sayer and his dedication to these patients touch
him. Leonard does all he can to help Dr. Sayers research.
When the patrons of the hospital learn of this breaking
miracle, they donate more money for the research to continue with the other patients in
the group, all of whom awaken after many years in a so called sleep. One patient wakes
after being in this condition for 43 years.
But all is not as it
seems
.
So How Does This Transfer Hold Up??
The anamophic video transfer is a bit ho hum. I found it irregular and sometimes not
pleasing to watch. There are occasional instances of slight ailiasing throughout the film.
The entire transfer has a very washed out look to it. I was happy that this was just a
feeling to the film, until I watch the trailer and the behind the scenes featurette. Here
the colours are much more saturated and eye catching, the skin tones are more vibrant and
you get a better feeling from the picture. Im not referring to the behind the scenes
footage but the actual film features shown here. There is also a softness to the transfer
there are times when the [picture is very sharp but generally it's a soft feel. In all I
was a little disappointed with the transfer.
Video Highlights
Ch 01 02:11 Some bad dust flecks
Ch 20 Almost the whole chapter has potential for great colour but alas there is
none.
The audio was also disappointing. All the tracks are Dolby
Surround 2.0. Fair enough this is a dialogue driven film but there are many opportunities
for use of driving surrounds. Unfortunately I was hard pressed to find much use of the
surrounds at all. The dialogue is always very sharp and clear and I could not find any
sync problems. The musical score by Randy Newman creates a perfect ambience for the film.
It doesnt really have a lot of effect on you but it is predominantly a nice
classical score fitting the mood of the film.
There is a striking volume difference between the film and
the other extras on the disk, which gave me a start when I changed to the extras and had
to jump for the remote to turn it down. There arent a lot of highlights from the
audio.
Audio Highlights
Ch 17 112:50 A disco setting and yet no use of surrounds
As far as extras go there isnt much. The trailer,
Cast and Crew Bios and the behind the scenes featurette. The featurette
isnt bad, bit of background information from the producer, Robin, and Robert. There
are included some making of scenes from the film and a short outtake. Nothing really
exciting Im afraid.
Overall I was most impressed with the story behind this
film and almost disturbed that it is a true story. It certainly is a film that everyone
should see for the human experience and the moving way that this film will touch you.
| PICTURE QUALITY |
7/10 muted and soft |
| SOUND QUALITY |
6.5/10 nothing spectacular |
| FEATURES |
3.5/10 sad |
| OVERALL |
7/10 great film, transfer
let it down. |
Review Equipment
TV: GE 68cm (16:9 selectable)
DVD: Samsung DVD907 (via S-Video)
Receiver/Proc: Sansui A505/Sony Amp & Yamaha DSP-E390
Speakers:-
Fronts: Wharfdale Diamond R6 (on a pair of custom made stands you'd KILL for)
Centre: Venturi
Rears: Sony bookshelf
- Reviewed 12th December 1999
|